Overruled
a judicial decision that invalidates or sets aside a previous ruling
Not followed
a court has declined to follow a decision of a court of co-ordinate jurisdiction in a case where the facts were similar.
Distinguished
a court decides that it won’t follow a previous decision even where it would otherwise be bound by it, as there is some important difference between the cases.
Adopted
the reasoning of a case which is not binding authority in New Zealand is used to support arriving at a decision in the current case
Applied
a court is applying a principle of a previous decision to the current case, the facts of which are materially different from those of the earlier case
Followed
a court is expressing itself as bound by a previous decision of a same/higher court in a case where the material facts were the same or substantially similar.
Obiter
– something said 'by the way' , statements about the law or the way it applies, by way of illustration, analogy or argument
Analysis
not the end itself – it is a tool to help us reason
ratio
the answer, and how they interrelate to precedent
Material facts
The facts that are legally relevant to the issue
Legal issue
The legal point in dispute in the case, Framed as a legal question based on the material facts (“whether …[insert material facts]”)
Distinguished
when the precedent case does not dictate outcome of current case – when they disagree – they distinguish the current case because they believe them to be different
Ratio Decidendi
The reason for a court's decision and is part of the judgement delivered at the end of a case - through analysis of the facts, the judge applies the appropriate rule or principle of law
Curia advisari vult
reserved decision – the judge took time to consider the decision
Res judicata
a case that is finished , it is settled
'J' after surname - which court
High Court
'P' as in president of what?
president of court of appeal
The weight of the case helps determine what?
how persuasive it may be – how the precedent has been treated In the past - the degree of legal similarity
A court is "bound" by precedent when?
- It is 'relevant' when compared to the current case – the facts and the laws
- From a hierarchically higher court in same jurisdiction
A precedent is persuasive when?
From a co-ordinate court same level or inferier in the hierarchy
A different jurisdiction ie england or canada
Precedent
something in the past that serves as a model for the future
A blueprint to be followed in similar cases
Stare decisis
the doctrine that courts will adhere to precedent in making their decisions. Stare decisis means “to stand by things decided” in Latin - To stand by decisions and not to disturb settled matter
The authority of Singh v ADLS (2002) helps to decide what?
which people can become high court workers
Lawyers are encouraged to do pro bono work for?
collegiality , altruism , and compulsion , and Duty
collegiality
(working with colleagues for a common cause)
altruism
(desire to help others without expecting anything in return)
compulsion
(requirements or expectations imposed by professional standards)
You can withhold from the Law Society info about criminal past if?
if criteria in the Criminal Records (Clean Slate) Act 2004 are met
Highest court in NZ – replaced the London based privy council in 2004
Supreme court
Judicial review
Judicial review is a constitutional function the review and possible invalidation of executive actions of the Government
Advesarial system
opposing parties act as adversaries, presenting their cases and competing to convince the judge and jury of their version of the facts - It places the responsibility of proving or disproving a case on the parties involved.
Inquisitorial system
a legal system in which the court is actively involved in investigating the facts of the case. This is distinct from an adversarial system, in which the role of the court is primarily that of an impartial referee.
Equity
set of remedies and associated procedures involved with civil law
Appellate jurisdiction
to hear appeals from lower courts
PDS - Public Defence Service
Government funded defence lawyers
Duty lawyers scheme
assists unrepresented defendants on their first day in criminal court
Police Dentention Legal Assistance scheme - PDLA
provide legal assistance to any person interrogated by police - can do even with your own lawyer if your lawyer isnt available
Speculative fee
Charge normal fee if case is successful
Bare percentage fee
fixed % of money winnings
Sliding percentage fee
% of money gets more as the case progresses through stages
Free premium fee
normal fee plus premium
In nz only two types of fee are legal
speculative and fee premium
Pro bono
free or disocounted price , a community involved case or charity
Civil jurisdiction / Civil Court System
resolving disputes between individuals or organisations started in the District Court
hierarchical court system
decision of a higher court is binding on lower courts
Equity / equitable court system
a type of court with the power to grant remedies other than monetary damages
municipal court system
a court of law with jurisdiction limited to a city or other municipality
Misrepresentation
when one party makes a false claim about a contract
Must be a lawyer for how long to become judge?
7 years - Coroners court is 5 years
bijuralism
The coexistence of two legal traditions in a single state
Ultra Vires
actions made by government bodies that go beyond the authority granted to them by law
Tortious acts / torts
common law actions where a person seeks damages for injuries sustained as a result of another person's wrongdoing
public act
A public act is one that has an impact on the general population
Local Acts
address public interest issues, although they only have an impact on a specific region of New Zealand
Millerson's common traits of a profession
skill based on a body of theoretical knowledge, an ethos of altruistic service, an ethical code of conduct
A lawyer who acted in a dishonourable way is likely to be found guilty of misconduct by what?
by the Disciplinary Tribunal s 7 Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006
what states the client's lawyer must "protect and promote" the client's interests without "compromising influences or loyalties" ?
Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care Rules 2008
In what year did the highest court in the New Zealand hierarchy (the Privy Council) get changed to supreme court ?
2004
Slippery slope
not making a legal judgement so as to avoid others from making it in future aka defence on necessity
Source of law
where a legal principle got its authority and validity, meaning, parliament or the courts
Acts are?
acts are of parliament; they can’t be used for to describe law from other bodies.
Bills are?
law that has not yet become law but has been introduced to parliament
Public Acts
acts that apply to the public
Local Acts
Local Acts - apply only to certain locations, such as a district council
Private Acts
are only applied to certain people, corporations,or groups
Members Bill’s
Members Bill’s are sponsored by members of parliament in a private capacity, it is not done by the whole political party, but if it is passed it becomes a public act like all others
subordinate or delegated legislation
Other bodies can make laws that bind citizens aslong as they can trace that power back to parliament - these are known as subordinate or delegated legislation - is made with little to no public engagement or involvement, in contrast to the parliament procedure; this adds worry that the law's quality may not be on par with that of Parliament.
Court structure of New Zealand
Supreme Court
Court of appeal
High court
District court
Criminal law
criminal law controls bad conduct by enforcing punishment
contract law
Rules on validity of agreement lands in contract law
Separation of powers
Separation of powers - is to prevent abuse of power
Constitutional law
describes the way which a country and its parts of government are put together. It also contains the rules they must abide by when creating laws.
Administrative law
Administrative law deals with the way in which government agencies interact/ treat private citizens. This includes fair and equal treatment of all people, and the exercise of discretion only on reasonable grounds.
Revenue law
Revenue law deals with tax and revenue, it enables the government to take tax from its citizens.
Land law
Land law covers the full idea of interests in land. How interests in land are created, restricted, and transferred is the subject of land law.
Property law
Property law covers things that are not an interest of land, making it personal property. Deciding who is entitled to ownership and possession of such property is the goal of property law.
Family law
Family law deals with matters of marriage, adoption, divorce, and similar events.
Restitution
Restitution is the reversal of an unfair payment. It is when one party has benefited at the expense of another.
International law
International law. There are a number of formal structures in international law. The United Nations is the most prominent of these. Next is the World Trade Organisation, which makes policy and determines conflicts about international free trade, and the International Court of Justice, which hears cases and renders rulings between nations.
Te Kōti Pīra
The Court of Appeal
Te Kōti ā Rohe
The District Court
Te Kōti Mana Nui
The Supreme Court
Te Kōti Matua
The High Court
Per incuriam
A finding of per incuriam means that a previous court judgment has failed to pay attention to relevant statutory provision or precedents
Materia Factus
a fact that is crucial to the determination of an issue at hand.
Jurisdiction
The scope of a court's power to do justice in cases brought before it
Territoriality
The territorial principle (also territoriality principle) is a principle of public international law which enables a sovereign state to exercise exclusive jurisdiction over individuals and other legal persons within its territory
In which document will you find this requirement: "(the person) must protect and
promote your interests
and act for you free from compromising influences or loyalties..."?
Lawyers: Conduct and Cient Care Rules 2008
In NZ, must the High Court follow a previous decision of the HC, which has substantially similar material facts?
No, HC decisions are persuasive in the HC
According to Webb, Dalziel and Cook, the requirement imposed by Rule 9 LCA (Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care) Rules 2008, that a lawyer must not charge more than is fair and reasonable, is a limit upon what?
A Lawyers pursuit of self interest
In a conflict between case and statutory law in NZ, the supreme law is
Statutory Law
Statutory law
the law that exists in legislatively enacted statutes especially as distinguished from common law
Under s 7 of LCA 2006, a lawyer that has acted in such a way deemed disgraceful or dishonorable by lawyers of good standing is likely to be found guilty of
Misconduct, by the Disciplinary Tribunal
Terry has frequent loud house parties that disturb his elderly neighbor Sue. Sue could have a claim against Terry for:
Nuisance
A type of tort, defined as the use of land in such a way that which unreasonably affects the use of adjacent land by its owner
Nuisance
All (1) ____ are appointed by the Governor General on the recommendation of the Attorney General exept the (2) ____ who is appointed by the GG on the recommendation of the (3) ____.
(1): High Court Judges, (2): Chief Justice, (3): Prime Minister
Outline the appellate jurisdiction of a judge of the District Court
Limited/statutory
2. Can hear appeals from administrative tribunal e.g motor vehicles disputes tribunal
[2014] 3 NZLR Intercity Group (NZ) Ltd v Nakedbus NZ Ltd. 177
High Court, Auckland
25, 26, 27 November 2013; 12 February 2014
Asher J. Cur adv vult
What does the info tell me?
The parties, the court, the judge, the dates of hearing and when judgment was made, the fact the decision was reserved and I can find the case in vol 3 of NZ Law Report page 177
Cur adv vult
used in a law report to indicate that the court's judgment was reserved (giving its decision at a later date in writing, after the trial or hearing)
A requirement for a person to practice in NZ, under Part 3 LCA 2006 and LCA (Lawyers: Admission) Rules 2008 / what court has a role in officializing lawyers?
Admission by the High Court / high court