Ethics
Personal and professional standards of behavior that guide normative social interactions and preserve morality.
PR and Ethics
We have different standards, perceptions, values and must satisfy; personal values, client needs, public interest, professional norms.
Strategic communication
Intends to; Advocate on issues, Influence knowledge, skills, behavior, Communicate messages, Moves other to actions
Questionable Ethical Behaviors
Misleading information, Promoting Inferior Products, Gain at the expense of others, Inappropriately influence policy/regs, Contributing to systematic decline
Theories of Ethical Behaviour: Selective Truth
A statement that is partly true, may be true in itself, but neglects the whole truth, or may use some deceptive element.
Case for Selective Truth
Total objectivity is not always practical, Alternative views will emerge, Not obliged to provide alternative views, Truth not as important as obligation to clients
Case against Selective Truth
Undermines ability to counsel on ethics, Undermines relationships w/ internal audiences, Runs counter to the preferred two-way. Symmetrical Concepts of public relations
Held legally liable if..
If they support or provide advice that involves illegal activity or a client or employer
Co-conspired if they..
Participate in an illegal action such as bribing a government official or covering up information of vital interest to the public’s health and safety.
Co-conspired if they..
Counsel and guides the policy behind on illegal action
Co-conspired if they..
Take a major personal part in the illegal action
Advertising Laws
Must be truthful and non-deceptive. Must have evidence to back up their claims. Cannot be unfair.
Libel and Slander = Defamation
Any false statement about a person (or organization) that creates public hatred, contempt, ridicule or inflict injury
What IS news?
Controversy of change. Rooted in “newness” or “interesting”. Meaning/appeal to readers’ need or curiosity (reporters ask “why would readers care?"). What we come to expect it to be. — Important, so we know how to frame the message and reach the right audience.
What IS NOT news?
Old/ already reported topic.
Just any event.
Personal opinion or interpretation.
A blatant cry for attention.
Media Relations
the practice of trying to persuade journalists to cover news stories that put certain policies or perspectives in the most favorable light. —** “just because you ignore them, does not mean they will ignore you”
**Earned Media
others write about you. More authenticity and validity if others write about you.
Newspaper/Magazines
Seeks access/ multiple sources
More in-depth reporting
Angles for relevance/ broadness
Television Radio
Driven by visual and sound bites
For more emotional and evocative
More conversational/ Talking heads
Online
Variety of medium, but speed driven
Lack of professional standards/ anyone can produce content
More interactive, nut also demand to stay on page
“If it BLEEDS, it leads” → violence is the lead story
Transformation by Digital News
Speed and easiness
Convergence
Scale and scope of communication
Activity and interactivity
Fluidity of digital media
Common characteristics of media organizations
Goal-directed/Competitive
Bureaucratized, routinized behaviors
Complex set of functions
Role positions
Departmentalization
Benefits of Organizational Routines
News if defined in similar ways across media
News sources cooperate
Daily information sharing with coworkers
Critique of Organizational Routines
Not reality; missing other stories/ events
Cooperations: Reporters are pressured to cooperate with news sources.
Standardization: Reporters are pressured to standardize
Pack Mentality: Reporters are pressured to agree.
Realities of News Work
Pressure on Reporters:
Short deadlines, demanding editors, reliance on officials, cost strictures, social pressures from other reporters.
RESULTED IN =
Standardized Practices:
Reliance on PR, Fluff stories on slow news days, breaking news events reported as formulas, compare notes, formulaic plotlines, pack journalism
Journalism’s Professional Norms: BTACCO
Balance/Fairness
Timeliness
Accuracy/Clarity
Comprehensiveness/Need to know
Civic Guardians/Watchdogs
Objectivity
**What is Objectivity?
It is a faith in facts, a distrust of opinions, and separating the two
Dominant, fundamental value of professional American journalism
A principle that requires a method or practice to achieve.
Objectivity is a principle that requires:
a method or practice to achieve —> Scientific Method: journalist adhere to the same method so they produce similar news:
political neutrality, prevailing standards of good taste, relying on documentary evidence, standard news formats packages, generalists instead of specialists, editorial review to enforce these methods
Balance:
Simulating objectivity by He said/ She said
Forcing balance can lead to :
undermining accuracy
neglecting the “other side'“ when an identifiable spokesperson if not easily found
false spokespersons when representation is ill defined
Objectivity as Routine Practices
Journalists adhere to the same methods, so they produce similar news.
Metaphor of news as a mirror
Critiques of Objectivity
Image is incomplete
Objects reflected are not passive
News is the product of social processes, this subjective
The ideal of objectivity is valuable but unobtainable
Accuracy/Clarity
Based on facts, evidence, what somebody said, intended to distribute facts efficiently
Intended to avoid embellishment, advocacy, interpretation
Make complex information accessible to average person (framing)
Consistency in reporting over time
Comprehensiveness
Intended to keep news serious, informative (often fails)
Tension between Morality Police vs. Sensationalism
Tries to be all things to all audiences
Ignores what public wants to ignore
Civic Guardians
Considered to be crucial to a working society & democracy
inform the electorate
spark debate
provide a channel for communication between the public and elites
surrogate for electorate
serve as a watchdog on government
Seven(Six) Media Relations Rules (PACK HF)
Be Accessible
Be Prepared
Be Honest
Be Knowledgeable
Be Fair
Be Consistent
Pitch
a tool — via email/social media — to hook media to cover your story or book an interview, etc.
Almost always, a media pitch is done by email, but also via social platforms, telephone, or traditional mail
Interview Do’s
Stick to what you know, follow up if needed
Pay attention to appearance and body language
Know when you’ve answered, then STOP
Repear messages
Frame your answers
Decide what you want to say; refine three positive points
Interview Don’ts
DO NOT
say no comment
Answer a questions with yes or no if necessary, incorporate the question into your answer
lie, tell jokes or use profanity
use buzz words
go “off record”
lose your temper
Comment on what others have said
Forget that the interview is not over until the reporter leaves
Crisis
negative events that could severely damage the operational functioning and reputation (business and persona) of a company
Key Reputational Risks of a crisis
Operational Viability
Reputational Credibility
Financial stability/sustainability
Legal Action
Common Crisis Features
Unexpected/loss of communication functions
Decisions/Demands for information are urgent
Routine business become increasingly difficult
outsiders take an unaccustomed interest
reputation suffers
communications are difficult to manage
Three Stages of Crisis Communication
Before , Identification/Discovery, and Anticipate
During, Prepping/Planning, Response/Control, Recovery, Engage And Manage
AFter, Learning, Post-crisis
Attribution Theory
Stakeholders look to attribute or interpret causes of negative or unexpected events. Attribution (narrative blame) may be assigned in a variety of ways or at different stages. An organization may be victim. Additionally, a reputational threat can be ‘intensified’ by crisis history and prior relational reputation.
Attribution Theory - Victim
Organization is a victim of the crisis (eg natural disasters, attack) - mirro reputational threat
Attribution Theory - Accident
Organization’s actions leading to the crisi were unintentional and in good faith (eg equipment or product failure, accusations from external stakeholders) - medium reputational threat;
Attribution Theory - Intentional/Negligent
Organization knowingly took inappropriate risk - major reputational threat
Attribution: Message Options
Engage
Tell the truth
Denial
Diminishment
Rebuilding/Rehabilitate
Bolstering/Reinforce
Silence is NEVER a strategy
Mature Crisis Management Tactics
Assess risks
Promote crisis-ready culture
Product plans
Define roles and responsibilities
Appoint crisis management team
Draw up communication plan
Produce contact and organization chart
Publish plans and conduct training
Text, review and practice
Crisis Management Team
Public Relations
Legal
Operations
Executive Suite
Security
Human Resources
Issues Management
An anticipatory process to detect emerging challenges or opportunities that may draw the attention of publics and stakeholders and require a response
Issues Management vs. Crisis Management
Differs from crisis management because it anticipates and pre-empts crisis or risk in a productive way (CSR). Helps to effectively respond to emerging issues to avert future crisis, but it’s a mistake to characterize the discipline as defensive and reactive.
Evident Crisis vs Perceived Crisis
Evident: a company actually experiences a problem to be resolved
Perceived: arises from public perceptions of a possible crisis
Core Elements of Crisis Plan: Implementation action
Identifying the extent of the crisis (what happened?)
Identifying multiple audiences (whom needs to know?)
Drafting the messages (what needs to be said?)
Choosing the channels to communicate (How?)
Coombs list of crisis communication strategies (P DISGRAAACED
This Crisis Management and Communications piece from the readings, Tim Coombs identifies different crisis messaging strategies:
• Attack accuser: confront person/ group claiming offense
• Denial: crisis manager asserts there is no crisis.
• Scapegoat: blame outside person/group
• Excuse: minimizes responsibility by denying intent to harm or claiming inability to control the events
• Provocation: crisis was response to another's actions
• Defeasibility: lack of information about events leading to the crisis situation (i.e., who knew?)
• Accidental: lack of control over events leading to the crisis situation (i.e., act of God)
• Good intentions: Organization meant to do well
• Justification: Minimize the perceived damage caused by the crisis.
• Reminder: Remind stakeholders about the past good works of the organization.
• Ingratiation (affiliation): Praise stakeholders for their actions
• Compensation: Proffer money or other gifts to victims
• Apology: Accept full responsibility for the crisis and asks stakeholders for forgiveness.
Patterson Corollary: Tell the Truth: Establishes trust, also opens liability—don't need to tell everything
Analysis of Issues: Categories
Current
Emerging
Societal
Issues Dimensions (BBNT)
Broad Impact: i.e., inflation economy, energy costs, health care access, jobs, transportation, privacy
Broad Abstract: Systematic, with a larger principle involved—i.e., abortion, racial/gender inequity, religious belief
Narrow Impact: Minimal affected, generally identified by issue groups i.e. Indian burial grounds, fracking, student debt
Technical: Complex/ usually involve distribution of political/economic power
Catalytic Model of Issues Management
Potential Stage
Imminent Stage
Current Stage
Critical Stage
Dormant
Social Issues Management Model Process:
Corporate Social Advocacy
Conceptualize
Definition, Legitimation, and Awareness
Issues Management Process (3 major categories)
Issue identification and analysis
strategic decision-making and action
evaluation
Internal Communication
Planned use of communication to systematically influence the knowledge, attitude and behaviours of current employees.
Changing Work Environment: Internal Communications strategies are more sophisticated
Today’s Workplace:
Highly competitive
Longer hours
Technology changes
Social influences
Today’s Employee
well educated
higher expectations
will have 10 before
diverse
want to understand more
Strategic use of Internal Communication : Corporate Strategy
Communicating company vision and values externally, so employees can explain strategic direction of organization and future priorities.
Strategic use of Internal Communication : Business development
Informing employees across the organization,
communicating successes, highlighting challenges, providing education and
training, and improving internal brand awareness
Strategic use of Internal Communication : Change Management
Ensuring employees are kept up to date with any plans to change or restructure the company, including new acquisitions, business integration, downsizing, and redundancy
Strategic use of Internal Communication : Employee Focus
Announcing staff changes, new hires, promotions; promoting cultural diversity, building employee engagement
Why Internal Communication Matters
Efficiency: Employees informed about goals, function, and performance. Lack of commitment may cost business $50 billion per year in quality defects, rework and repair costs, absenteeism and reduced productivity, (Cutlip, Center & Broom, 2006)
Encourage innovation/share knowledge: Create dynamic for improving operational processes, identify talented workers, make sense of the organization
Establish positive cultural values: Show values/promote understanding among employees about corporate goals, and connect people and activities.
Satisfaction: Ensures trust, loyalty, and satisfaction. Izzo & Withers (2000) found employee retention rates were 44 percent higher in organizations with engaged and committed employees.
Organizational Culture
The shared values, habits, and beliefs of employees that affect performance and purpose driven collaboration. Tied to employee recruitment/retention, company profitability, and customer loyalty. Culture is how things get done.
Employees are Brand Ambassadors
Communicate the vision : Ensure employees understand the “who we are” and “what we do” and can clearly articulate it to their networks. It’s important that everyone is speaking from the same page.
Give Permission : Employees hesitate to share information about their employers on social media, in case they get into trouble. If you want your employees to post, tweet and snap about your organization, provide a social media policy of dos and don’ts to on what they can and can't share publicly, as well as how to properly refer to the company and your products. If there is specific language they should not use, be sure to let them know.
Create great content they can use: Create compelling and relevant content that employees can share on social media: i.e., press releases, infographics, videos and behind-the-scenes looks at the organization. Include sample posts, tweets and hashtags they can use.
Let employees contribute: When given the chance, employees are more likely to share when they are involved.
Internal Communication Models: Conventional (Hierarchical) Communications
Vets authority with upper management. Info flows vertically to strategically plan and deliver messages that inspire, guide, and engage employees.
SMCR: Information Source encodes Message which is sent through a Channel to Receiver
company wide announcements
KPI overviews and progress reports
Employees know roles/responsibility
Internal communication Models: Continuous Communications
Designed to capture and address staff concerns/suggestions in a timely manner. Not all communications affect employees equally, requiring tailoring messages to distinct teams and staff groups.
Various channels available — (eg. online platforms, face-to-face meetings, Q&As, teleconferences, all staff, intranet).
Empathize — not just the facts, but tips on how to navigate change/performance.
Continuously ask for employee feedback using (surveys, groups sessions, forums) Most Importantly: Follow through on staff feedback
Internal communication Models: Two Multi-way Communications
An enriched way of communication from two-way communication in creating functional communication channels and responsibilities.
Relationships between departments, units, individuals, and teams decide communications. based in receivers’ needs, not transmitter’s.
Peer-to-peer sharing. Teams visible and engaged with one another, sharing intelligence, asking questions and generally supporting each other.
Organized ways to convene teams, discuss work, and generally get things done.
Investor Relation Mission
promotes a company’s narrative to analyst and investors to achieve a market valuation that reflects understanding of the business, its growth strategy, and prospects for how the company grows.
It communicates the company’s financial strategies and results to everyone with an interest (eg stakeholders, market analysts, find advisors, journalists, regulators, employees) and ensure information is relevant, correct, timely, and understandable.
Maintaining relationship with shareholders and others in the financial community
Investor Relation Responsibilities
Promote: clear and concise messaging
Relationship building: outreach to investors
Dissemination: reliable and transparent financial info
Compliance: Adhere to SEC laws, IRS, accounting standards
Interpretation: repart MKT intelligence to management
Investor Relations Strategic Functions
Create IR Fact Sheet (Pitch Book): Narrative playbook to synchronize message.
Attract new analyst coverage: Target analysts covering extended peer group of companies consistent with company story.
Research prospective shareholders: Find holders who respond to your story.Market investment style aligned with story
Maintain ongoing comparable valuation analysis. Track consensus revenue,estimates for peers to educate analysts and investors on valuation drivers.
Ensure regulatory compliance: All verbal and written communications must meet regulatory and legal requirements. Disclosures, whether positive or negative, should be candid, balanced and timely to maintain credibility.
Laskin’s Four (+one) Keys to IR Success
1) Support Fair Share Price by knowing and communicating company’s investment proposition/future prospects--and building trust, reliability and transparency to the widest pool of potential investors--helps achieve an appropriate comparative valuation. Help capital markets understand a fair valuation of a company - Providing evidence of growth opportunities - Demonstrating historical and future performance/success - Engendering trust in corporate sustainability
2) Improve Liquidity of Stock by attracting new investors and raising demand for the company's stock can help raise the liquidity of a company's shares to enhance the company's worth and make it easier for investors to trade.
3) Enhanced Analyst Coverage by knowing who is trading your stock and focus on building a diversified shareholder base. Investors WANT metrics (e.g., sales, profits, debt-equity structure, Free Cash Flow, etc.) to ensure their capital is being deployed in value-accretive activities. Income smoothing is a kind of earnings management (‘managing’ as defined as reported earnings to meet analysts’ expectations) Earnings management is stimulated by the direct link between accounting earnings and share price (P/E ratio).
4) Building & Maintaining Investor Relationships by building and maintaining investor relationships with hundreds or thousands of shareholders. engaging them effectively at every stage.
5) IR intelligence—i.e., systematising investor views and competitor situations, then channelling that information back to management.
IR Audiences: Investors
typically fall into three categories: Individual investors, Institutional investors (i.e., collective funds, mutual funds, hedge funds, etc.), and “Day- traders.”
Research prospective shareholders: Find investors who respond to your story. Market investment style aligned with story.
Maintain shareholders relationships.
Monitor IR activity: Track outgoing/incoming calls, emails and investor downloads. Establish metrics for investor and analyst contacts.
Monitor shareholder activity:Track changes in holdings for yourself and peers to detect shifts and company-specific news.
Analyze and predict investor behavior to management: Monitor investor activity, valuation parameters, and outcomes to guide strategic planning.
IR Audiences: Analysts
employees of brokerage firms or institutional investors (e.g., banks, insurance companies, mutual fund managers) who study companies and make buy-and-sell recommendations on stocks of these companies. Most specialize in a specific industry.
Sell-side Analysts: work for brokerage firms whose analyses and recommendations on specific companies that are used by stockbrokers as vehicles to promote stocks and other securities to customers. Sell- Side is focused almost exclusively by volume because brokerage house revenues are driven by trading and deal flow.
Buy-side Analysts: typically work for institutional investors (portfolio managers) that purchase securities for their own accounts and use analysts to watch specific industries or major economic sectors. Buy- side is an asset gathering business and is thus typically focused by market capitalization, benchmarks/indices, long-term performance and risk measurement.
IR Audiences: Regulators
SEC, Auditors, accountants, certificatons, Credit agencies, US congress, lawmakers, etc.
IR Audiences: News Media
General Media: General business news in everyday newspaper, magazines, radio, television, and digital media affect public perceptions.
Financial Media: General financial or business media (Wall Street Journal, Financial Times, Business Week, CNBS, etc.) or industry specific (trade magazines to specific vertical industries.)
Digital Media: Sites that specialized in news of interest to the investment community (Yahoo Finance, The Street.com) other sites operated by investment/brokerage firms offer historical information, breaking news as well as reports prepared by the firms’ analyst.
What is public policy?
A plan of actions undertaken by government officials to achieve some broad purpose affecting a substantial segment of a nation’s citizens
It inputs shape a government’s policy decisions and strategies to address problems.
Policymaking Process
Legislative
Referenda
Regulatory Agencies
Judicial Review
Government’s Ability to Influence Business
Market Regulation
Economic Regulations
Social Regulations
Fiscal Policy
How does the government/policy making influence business?***
Regulation: Market, economic and social regulation
Tax Policies: raising or lowering taxes on businesses
Trade policies: encouraging or discouraging trade with other countries
Industrial/infrastructure policies: directing economic resources towards to the development of specific industries
Monetary policies: affect the supply and demand as well as the value fo the nations currency
Lobbying
the act of attempting to influence decisions made by officials in the government, most often legislators or members of regulatory agencies. It is done by many different types of people and organized groups, including individuals in the private sector, corporations, fellow legislators or government.
The three C’s of Lobbying: Consistency, Conciseness, Credibility
Consistency, Conciseness, Credibility
Corporate lobbying Strategies: Information Strategy/Direct Lobbying
It is about education, information, and relationships.
Lobbying
Testimony
Direct Communication
Ex: Think
Thanks / Trade Groups
Corporate lobbying Strategies: Coalition
It is a group of individuals, businesses think thanks, or political organizations that pool their resources influence legislation.
stakeholder coalitions
Trade associations
Think thanks
Party loyalty
Ideological disposition
Corporate Political Strategies: Grassroots & Astroturf
It seeks to influence specific legislation by encouraging the public to contact legislators about that legislation. AstroTurf appears to be grassroots, but it is really organizational manipulation.
Corporate Political Strategies: Revolving Door of Influence
Officials in the executive branch, Congress and senior congressional staffers spin in and out of the private and public sectors, bringing with them privilege, power, access and money to the powerful appropriations committees, which interest are employing former members of congress to lobby on their behalf.
**Iron Triangle of Policymaking:
the policy making relationship among the congressional committees, bureaucracies, and interest groups.
Congress
Interest groups
Bureaucracies
The main policymaking institution in the USA
Political Actions Committees
Independently incorporated organizations that can solicit contributions and then channel those funds to candidates seeking political office but must disclose their finances to the FEC and cannot coordinate with candidates or political parties
Dark Money
Independently incorporate organizations that can raise and spend funds for the “Public good” (not for a specific candidate) but do not have to disclose their donors.
Strategic Global Communication
International communication balances a broad spectrum of publics and cultures to avoid cultural differences that could lead to misunderstandings and to find common ground to work together
Multicultural (or intercultural) Communication
a symbolic, interpretive, transactional, contextual process in which people from different cultures create shared meanings often. Focuses on shared core value messages that can transcend cultural differences in language, customs, faith traditions, and/or ideologies.
Cross-Cultural Communication
Is the sending of a message from one unique culture to another unique culture while still meeting the cultural norms of the specific country the message is being sent.
Generic/Specific Theories
Incorporated two separate concepts of international communications into as integrated comprehensive theory
Generic Theory:
Argued that international public relations has to centrally standardized to preserve global management strategies and consistent messages
Specific Theory
Also considered, “adaptive localization”. Argued that centralization could not possibly respond to local cultural differences and communication mandates.
Excellence Theory
Integration of generic theory’s principles and specific theory’s applications that falls “midway between an ethnocentric theory that public relations is the same everywhere” - requiring cultural mediators, linguistic translation and strategic experts
Basics of Cross-Cultural Communication
understand what people do and why they do them
Linguistic fluency does not equal cultural fluency
Be Flexible - business vs friendship? / inter-business = inter-personal relationships
Be respectful - sincerely approach business dealings
Be non judgemental
Listen vs. Arguing
Understand that other political, religious, personal ideas exist
Avoid assumption, jokes which are misunderstood.
use symbols, diagrams and pictures