What were the problems with public health in medieval towns?
Growing population (more waste + clean water)
Waste in streets (no sewers --> public privies and cess pits)
Human waste seeps into drinking water
Animal waste --> butchers throwing animal body parts in street
Rivers take waste away but also used for drinking water
Commercial business waste --> Leather
How was public health in medieval towns improved?
Lead/wood pipes for fresh water
Privies in some houses or public privies
1388 Law --> no throwing rubbish into streets BUT no law to enforce it.
Tradesmen encouraged to keep places clean
How was the public health in monasteries different to towns in the middle ages?
Location --> away from towns
Knowledge --> monks could read and write so learnt from ancient ideas
Routines --> washing/eating/rest (bath once a month)
Monasteries were next to clean drinking water
Why did monks believe in cleanliness?
Because cleanliness = holiness
What kinds of surgery were carried out in the medieval period?
Blood letting (withdrawal of blood) --> most common
Trepanning (drilling a hole in the skull) --> let the demons out (for people who actually had epilepsy)
Amputation --> cauterisation afterwards using a hot iron to burn a wound to stop the flow of blood
What were the problems with medieval surgery?
Lack of training --> barber surgeons
No understanding of bacteria or dirt carrying disease
No effective pain killers
Couldn't help patients with deep wounds
Sometimes thought pus in a wound was good
How were barber surgeons trained?
Observation
New ideas circulated from books from the Islamic world
Battlefield surgeons tried new techniques
How was medieval Islamic Medicine better than medieval European medicine?
Religious duty
Individuals
Stability
Knowledge
Why did the Islamic people have a religious duty towards medicine?
Prophet Muhammed encouraged medical learning
Sickness was seen as something to be treated
-"For every disease Allah has given a cure"
Who were individuals that helped Islamic medicine?
Al-Razi
Ibn Sina
What did Al-Razi do?
Wrote 150 books
Challenged medicine
His ideas were later used across Europe
What did Ibn Sina do?
Wrote encyclopaedia of medicine
Discussed conditions like obesity and anorexia
Distinguished between measles and smallpox
Why was the Islamic Empire stable?
It was ruled by a single caliph
What did the Islamic Empire encourage?
The pursuit of knowledge
What did the Islamic Empire build?
Librairies
Many Greek texts were translated into Arabic
A hospital in Baghdad (with a medical school and librairies in it)
What was the focus on in Islamic medicine?
Treating patients, not just caring
What was considered the best way to get better in European medicine?
Prayer
People went on pilgrimages to get better
What did the church control?
Education
What did the church not like?
The pursuit of new ideas
Who was Roger Bacon?
A monk
Why was Roger Bacon arrested?
For suggesting doctors should do original research
How many hospitals did the church found in England?
700
They were clean and had good food
Had specialist ones for people with mental illness or lepers
What did monks copy out?
Books by ancient scholars like Galen
What were the 4 Humours?
blood, phlegm, yellow bile, black bile
What did Hippocrates believe about the 4 Humours?
That imbalance caused illness
Focus on diet to improve balance rather than praying
How did Hippocrates believe you should diagnose a patient?
Look at the symptoms and make a judgement
Focus on what you could see
How did Hippocrates help society?
Hippocratic Oath "Do no harm"
Doctors still make this oath today
How did Hippocrates hinder society?
He had no real understanding of the human body
What did Galen believe?
He believed in the use of opposites.
Liver circulates blood and then burns out.
How did Galen help society?
Discovered that arteries carried blood
How did Galen hinder society?
Believed in 4 humours
Believed that blood was created in the liver
When was the Renaissance?
1300-1600
How did the Renaissance help medicine improve?
People inspired to criticise ancient texts
Educated people wanted to discover, not just accept what the church said.
Printing press invented in 1451 --> books were cheap and ideas spread quickly.
New weapons --> gunpowder = new types of wounds.
New lands discovered --> bought back new medicine.
Who were the main Renaissance medical practitioners?
Paré
Harvey
Vesalius
Jenner
Hunter
What did some people still believe, even in the Renaissance?
Miasma + 4 humours causing illness
Punishment from God
How did Renaissance people try to treat illnesses using old methods?
Bloodletting continued
Superstition continued --> King's touch could cure disease
Herbal remedies continued
Barber surgeons + wise women continued
How did Renaissance people try to treat illness using new methods?
Opium used as anaesthetic
New treatments discovered --> Quinine (a bark from South America) for malaria
Lemon/limes to treat scurvy (vitamin C)
Trained Doctors (still used some traditional methods though)
What are quacks?
Showy, travelling salesmen who sold medicine
Fake doctors
How did hospitals change during the Renaissance?
New hospitals built --> 5 in London with different wards for different diseases
Medical schools to train doctors
More evidence based approach to illness, not a punishment from God
1776 Edinburgh hospital had a pharmacy and gave free medicine to the poor
1746 STD hospital in London
-1749 Maternity hospital set up in London
What was the Great Plague?
An epidemic in 1665 that killed 100k in London
How did people try to treat the 1665 Great Plague?
Bleeding with leeches
Smoking/ smelling vinegar and roses to avoid miasma
Escaping --> King Charles and his court escaped
What did the Plague Doctor do?
Offered ineffective treatments
Wore a mask with herbs to avoid breathing in miasma
What were the similarities in the approach used for the 1347-8 Black Death and the 1665 Great Plague?
No knowledge of bacteria
Ineffective treatments and avoiding miasma --> using frogs, pigeons, and snakes to draw out the poison
What were the differences in the approach used for the 1347-8 Black Death and the 1665 Great Plague?
Largely confined to London
More organised this time --> better quarantine to stop spread, law passed in 1666 which ended trade and boarder closed with Scotland to limit disease entering from Britain
Officials recognised link between dirt and disease, so more effort to clean streets
Better disposal of bodies --> mass plague pits
Gatherings of crowds --> plays and games were banned
What did Andreas Vesalius do?
Illustrated textbook giving accurate depictions of the human body
Showed Galen's errors --> there was a difference between an ape and a human breast bone.
Challenged Galen's beliefs that Human and pig anatomy were similar
In England where were Vesalius' drawings published?
The comprediosa which was very popular in the 1500s
How did Vesalius help society?
As he dissected stolen dead bodies of criminals, he showed how to do proper human dissections and famous anatomists followed his approach
How did Vesalius Hinder society?
He did not find any new medical cures
What did Ambroise Paré do?
Ran out of hot oil to cauterise wounds on the battlefield and improvised with egg white, turpentine and rose oil --> worked well and less painful
Bought back Galen's use of ligatures to stop bleeding
Invented Crow's beak clamp to stop bleeding temporarily
Published "Works on Surgery" in English and French
Designed false limbs for soldiers
What was Paré's impact in Britain?
William Clowes used Paré's work to inform his own
Clowes was Queen Elizabeth's surgeon
What did William Harvey do?
Dissected lizard and human hearts
Understood the heart's role as a pump
Experimented by pumping blood the wrong way, proving blood could only be pumped one way
Proved blood circulated around the body, not made in the liver (challenged Galen)
How did Harvey help society?
Fundamental understanding of how body works --> in long term leads to blood transfusions
How did Harvey hinder society?
Took a long time for people to accept
People liked blood letting so it wasn't accepted well
In the 1700s, what was the biggest killer?
Smallpox
What was used to try and prevent smallpox?
Inoculation (giving a small dose of the disease through crushed up smallpox scabs) --> didn't always work, could still kill and pass onto others
Poor couldn't afford
It was popular --> made doctors rich
What did Edward Jenner discover?
Cowpox was a milder version of smallpox that made you immune to it
Learnt this from milkmaids
Experimented on an 8 year old boy
How was Jenner's "Vaccination" received?
Wasn't taken seriously as he wasn't a city doctor
Doctors tried his technique but made mistakes which made some people ill
Royal Family was vaccinated --> Jenner given £10000 to do research
1800s --> technique used across America + Europe
1853 --> British government made smallpox vaccine compulsory
What did John Hunter do?
Surgeon to King George III
1771 wrote Natural History of Teeth
1786 wrote a book on Venereal Disease
Wrote books on disease, cancer and circulation of the blood
Collected + studied 3000 anatomical specimens --> stuffed animals and diseased organs.
Pumped wax into blood vessels to study circulation
Demanded careful observation in surgery
Gave himself gonorrhoea germs
Saved a man's leg through surgery rather than just amputating
How did John Hunter help society?
Taught 100s of other surgeons including Edward Jenner in his SCIENTIFIC approach
Inspired young surgeons to become great medical teachers and professors in both Britain and America
What was surgery like in 1800?
No effective pain relief so it was terrifying and had to be done quickly
The painkillers that were available were difficult to measure (opium) or not appropriate (alcohol —> caused heavy bleeding)
Why were there objections to chloroform?
Early confusion about amounts of pain relief needed
Hannah Greener died after a toenail operation —> wrong amount
Some surgeons thought soldiers should put up with the pain
Pain seen as God’s will
Why did Chloroform become more accepted?
Queen Victoria used it for childbirth
Made it fashionable and acceptable
Still high death rate from infection though
How had surgery changed by 1900?
Nitrous Oxide “laughing gas” used in 1844 when American dentist Horace Wells used it to remove teeth
Ether —> effective but had dangers, used by an American dentist 1842, used to amputate a leg in 1846 —> difficult to inhale and highly flammable
Who was Chloroform discovered by?
James Simpson in 1847
Most effective and safest
What were the problems related to infection?
Surgery carried high risk of infection
Confusion over why infection happened —> where did microbes come from and what did they do?
Surgeons tried to keep patients healthy and the wound clean —> if it became infect they used cauterising or acids to burn away affected tissues
What was the Theory of Spontaneous generation?
The idea that decay caused microbes and that all microbes were the same
The microbes just appeared out of nowhere
What was Germ Theory?
Published in 1861 by French scientist Louis Pasteur
Proved spontaneous generation wrong
Proved germs caused decay
Carried out Swan Neck Flask experiment to show how liquids went off when exposed to air
What was Joseph Lister’s approach?
Spray Carbolic acid on wounds, hands and equipment
1865 mended the fractured leg of a young boy and didn’t have to amputate because he wrapped the wound in bandages soaked in carbolic acid. Boy recovered in 6 weeks
Didn’t understand complexity of microbes though —> still operated in street clothes
Why did many surgeons not like Lister’s approach?
Many unwilling to be proved wrong about old theories
Many didn’t like using Carbolic acid as it dried the skin, irritated the lungs and took the nurses a long time to prepare
What was Pasteur’s connection to Koch?
Used Koch’s research on identifying specific bacteria to develop vaccines diseases like Anthrax and Cholera
Who was Robert Koch?
German bacteriologist - founder
Developed methods to identify specific bacteria by staining and photographing microbes
Used mice to prove that specific bacteria caused specific illnesses
What was Koch’s impact on scientific understanding?
Identified microbe for Anthrax
Developed methods to allow scientists to identify specific bacteria
This allowed them to develop vaccines
What was Koch’s connection to Pasteur?
Koch’s work was informed by Pasteur’s initial germ theory
He applied Pasteur’s theory to human diseases
What was Lister’s connection to Pasteur?
Read Pasteur’s work and applied it’s theories to his surgical work
What was the Industrial revolution?
A period of great change (1750-1900) in Britain
Britain changed from being agricultural to industrial
Population grew by 50%
Thousands of people moved to cities to work in factories —> this caused problems
What kind of diseases were common during the Industrial period?
Typhoid
Tuberculosis
Cholera
What did people think caused disease during the Industrial period?
Miasma
Before Germ Theory —> spontaneous generation
Beliefs changed due to Germ Theory and improvements in public health/more government action and individuals such as Chadwick, Snow and Bazelgette
What was the state of Public Health in the early 19th century?
Rapid industrialisation —> overcrowding, poor/back-to-back housing, lack of toilets, contaminated drinking water, no rubbish collections, street cleaning of sewers
What were the cholera outbreaks?
1831 —> 50K killed
Then further outbreaks
Carried by water but people thought it was in the air
People knew there was a link between disease and poverty but not why
How did Typhoid and TB spread?
Crowded areas
Poor sanitation
unhygienic conditions
What did the 1848 Public Health Act say?
Central boards of health set up to improve PH in towns
Local boards of health —> didn’t do much
Towns were encouraged to spend money on cleaning up the streets (most didn’t but Liverpool and Birmingham did)