knowt logo

2.4 Stem Cell Dilemmas

Adult stem cells in medicine:

  • To treat burns (adult skin stem cells from patient’s own body so that they are not rejected)

  • To treat leukaemia (adult blood stem cells taken from willing donors). The donors must match.

Embryonic stem cells in research:

  • A lot more controversial (as embryos cannot ‘give permission’)

  • Embryos from IVF (that are no longer needed) are usually used

  • Legal in the UK, but very restricted

  • Possibilities to treat diabetes and paralysis

Embryonic stem cells

Adult stem cells

Advantages

Can differentiate into any specialised cell

Can be accepted without rejection

From willing, consenting donors

Well tested and reliable

Disadvantages

Ethical issues

Development of therapies is slow, expensive and difficult to control

Possibility of rejection

Can only differentiate into certain cells

Therapeutic cloning:

  1. Disease-free cells are taken from the patient (to avoid rejection)

  2. An egg is transferred to the cells

  3. Cells that can be used for treatment are formed

A

2.4 Stem Cell Dilemmas

Adult stem cells in medicine:

  • To treat burns (adult skin stem cells from patient’s own body so that they are not rejected)

  • To treat leukaemia (adult blood stem cells taken from willing donors). The donors must match.

Embryonic stem cells in research:

  • A lot more controversial (as embryos cannot ‘give permission’)

  • Embryos from IVF (that are no longer needed) are usually used

  • Legal in the UK, but very restricted

  • Possibilities to treat diabetes and paralysis

Embryonic stem cells

Adult stem cells

Advantages

Can differentiate into any specialised cell

Can be accepted without rejection

From willing, consenting donors

Well tested and reliable

Disadvantages

Ethical issues

Development of therapies is slow, expensive and difficult to control

Possibility of rejection

Can only differentiate into certain cells

Therapeutic cloning:

  1. Disease-free cells are taken from the patient (to avoid rejection)

  2. An egg is transferred to the cells

  3. Cells that can be used for treatment are formed